China’s ambition to be “the workshop of the world” is well on its way to
being realised. A single factory in the country’s southern province of
Guangdong, for example, manufactures around 40% of the world’s microwave ovens.
As for
Chinese consumers, there is a huge appetite for products taking in everything
from L’Oréal shampoo to IKEA furniture.
There has been a shift in the growth agenda in China, however. John
Stuttard, a member of the China-Britain Business Council and an adviser to
PricewaterhouseCoopers, says that the outlook is still for 10%-plus growth.
But the Chinese Communist Party authorities are increasingly concerned
about the lack of investment and growth in some of the more rural or moribund
rustbelt areas of China.
Political and regulatory environment
With China’s membership of the World Trade Organization (WTO), the political leadership is working to embrace free market economic reform within what is still emphatically a communist system. But even now, to navigate all the state and local laws successfully it is imperative for a business to use local experts.
One significant change in China in the last few years is that the court system has improved considerably. Tim Clissold, author of the best-selling (and highly recommended) book Mr China, says that, in the event of a legal dispute with a trade partner, “You’re much more likely to get a fair judgement these days than you would have done five or six years ago.”
Clissold adds that the government is dealing “robustly” with the problem of corruption, whether in the business world or government.
Doing business there
One of the most important words in the Chinese business lexicon is
guanxi. It means relationships, and the significance of it is that to
succeed in business it is necessary to build up the right relationships with the
right people.
In most industries it is possible to establish a “wholly foreign owned enterprise” (WFOE). That doesn’t necessarily mean that it is always a good idea to do so. Many businesses enter into joint ventures so as to be able to work with local companies that have the necessary guanxi with business and government.
“Despite their drawbacks, joint ventures are likely to remain as the most viable entry option,” according to a KPMG report on the Chinese machine tool industry. The WFOE structure, though, is “likely to become more common after foreign companies become more experienced in China”.
The currency – variously known as the renminbi, RMB or the yuan – is not freely convertible on the capital account, but under the WTO agreement it should be possible to get dividends out of the country.
“If you can’t it’s probably because of some administrative procedure that hasn’t received local approval,” says Stuttard.
The RMB slightly loosened its link to the dollar last year to placate US concerns that the exchange rate was too skewed in favour of China’s exporters.
Management/accountancy staff
The influx of western and Japanese businesses into China has significantly raised the overall quality of local managers who have been trained in the ways of modern business methods and financial controls. But although there is still a shortage, incoming businesses generally recognise the importance of having Chinese managers.
“We don’t see clients send a whole team to China to manage their business,” says Jeffrey Wang of Business Development Asia, which is associated with Close Brothers investment bank. Wang advises western businesses looking to acquire Chinese companies. “We typically see them send one guy. Occasionally, they send a team of people to come to support on a short-term basis or financial people helping them to run the system for a couple of months.”
Making a success of business
Be patient. Decision-making can be a slow process, particularly if government officials are involved. The culture is based around deference to superiors and hence a reluctance to make a decision.
Good due diligence is vital, as not only is the quality of financial reporting variable, but “related party transactions” can create problems for the unwary. One way to improve your success rate is to be prepared to own less than 100%of a business. This can help you “structure a company in such a way that it can still motivate the local team so that their interests are tied up very much with your interests”, says Maggie Eather in PwC’s Shanghai office.
Understand the importance of not causing someone to lose face. Your Chinese opposite number may haggle, but will rarely embarrass you by saying no, and it can be easy to misinterpret as yes a comment that was not necessarily meant to be encouraging.
Don’t expect to make a quick buck. “People are taking a much longer-term view than they have done in the past,” says Stuttard. “It might take you 10 years to make a profit.”
Case study: Drinking buddies
|
“China has changed dramatically since we first went there in the early 1990s and had a look,” says Malcolm Wyman, FD of the Londonbased but South Africaoriginated SABMiller brewing company. “We took the view that we needed to go in as a jointventure partner, as opposed to trying to run something on the other side of the world on our own. We spent two years in a courtship dance with a company called China Resource Enterprises – which was doing exactly the same thing with us. We spent a long time feeling each other out to see whether we would be the right partners. And after about 18 months or so we signed an agreement. “We are now the secondlargest brewer in China. We have breweries all over the country. We still operate as a joint venture and I would say that we categorise our relationship as being the norm. We have our ups and we have our downs, but over time we think it’s been a very good partnership. Both parties have worked tirelessly for the joint venture. We’ve managed to resolve any differences that we may have. “Our partner is a Hong Kong-listed business, 51%- owned by the government of the People’s Republic of China – the Ministry of Finance and Trade – and the people who sit on its board are all government officials appointed by Beijing. “You hear many stories about China. Yes, it is very different to run a business in China. You have to work through the Chinese. It’s not possible for westerners to get enough Mandarin-speaking Chinese to run the business of 50 million hectolitres spread right across China, so you need to work through a few senior Chinese people. “We think we’re good at adapting to cultures rather than forcing a culture onto our acquisitions. We think that’s made us a lot more successful in our partnership arrangements.” |
Inflows and outflows
| Exports | $437.9bn |
|
Office equipment |
$62.6bn |
|
Clothing |
$52.1bn |
|
Telecoms |
$45.0bn |
|
Electrical machinery |
$42.4bn |
|
Footwear |
$13.0bn |
| Imports | $413.1bn |
|
Electrical machinery |
$79.8bn |
|
Petroleum products |
$26.7bn |
|
Office equipment |
$24.2bn |
|
Other machinery |
$21.0bn |
|
Telecoms |
$19.5bn |
| Net foreign direct investment | $51.0bn |