It looks as though trouble is brewing in the world economy in 2008
There are many areas of uncertainty not least how the present credit crunch
plays out but, overall, the global economy (measured by GDP) is set to grow by
3.2% in 2008, according to the normally reliable predictions of D&B Country
But there’s a catch, says Darren Middleditch, economist at D&B. “This is
predicated on our expectation that the US economy does not slip into recession
as a result of the tightening of credit conditions. However, the risk of a hard
landing is non-trivial and our relatively upbeat assessment could also face
downside risks from the continuation of high world oil prices though if the
global economy were to slow markedly, demand for hydrocarbons would drop anyway,
causing prices to fall,” he says.
So if US growth is slowing, where will expansion come from?
The Bric economies Brazil, Russia, India, China look set to
continue their rise, although the conditions may not be as buoyant as in the
recent past. China’s rampant growth rate may slip back from 11.7% to 9.8% in
2008, according to Middleditch. “Inflationary pressures will continue to mount
and may lead to an eventual policy response in late 2008 that includes allowing
the currency to appreciate more realistically,” he warns.
India’s economy may also have a tougher time. “Growth is set to moderate more
markedly as a result of the impact of slowing industrial output and the negative
impact of higher interest rates, slower global demand conditions and the
strength of the rupee,” says Middleditch.
Some of the gloss may be knocked off Russia’s economy because of the slow
pace of real economic reform. Even the buoyant hydrocarbons sector could face
problems as inward investment has been discouraged by Russia’s tendency to
expropriate assets that start to perform well. Meanwhile, Middleditch expects
Brazil to continue to grow on the back of strong consumer spending.
So what does the global picture mean for the UK economy?
Britain has been relatively hard hit by the credit crunch. With tighter
lending, there could be a knock-on effect on property. But Iain Hasdell, a
senior partner at KPMG, takes an optimistic view. “I foresee the lack of
volatility in UK interest rates and inflation continuing in 2008,” he says.
“This will provide a sound platform for all sectors of the economy that have
growth plans. I expect to see significant growth in some of the UK’s emerging
sectors including the environmental technology field complementing
incremental growth in more traditional domains such as financial services. But
manufacturing will continue to be a challenged area of the economy.”
Not every commentator takes such a sanguine view. “Debt levels are high and,
with the ongoing uncertainty over interest rates, consumers will be spending
less in 2008,” says Ryan Kneale, market analyst at BetsForTraders.com. “Major
retail stocks will be hurting and many chains are tipped to extend their sales
calendar and drop prices further to encourage consumer spending. The danger is
that with stretched incomes and sky-high oil prices, consumers will be turning
to plastic, plunging further into debt.”
The big question, though, is will the credit crunch continue into
Most commentators, including Ismail Ertürk, senior fellow in banking at
Manchester Business School, agree there’s still more bad news to come from the
banks hit by exposure to sub-prime lending. The question is what impact this
will have on businesses that want to borrow in 2008. An autumn Deloitte survey
of 51 FDs found that 50 of them agreed the crunch would reduce the availability
of credit generally. But only 13 thought it would be a significant reduction.
If there is less liquidity in debt markets in 2008, there could be problems
for some companies, warns Jason Green, a director a PricewaterhouseCoopers
Corporate Finance. “The buoyancy in debt markets over the past couple of years
has allowed some corporates and private equity firms to shore up poor
performance through financial re-engineering. Debt markets will not be as
buoyant in 2008 and borrowers with patchy performance and weak credit metrics
will not be able to rely on increased borrowings as a ‘get out of gaol free
But Andrew Burrell, associate director at Experian, argues that after several
years of good profitability and cost control, most firms’ balance sheets are
reasonably healthy. “As a result, external finance is less of an issue than in
the past for companies.
“A general slowdown in the economy is expected to curb the demand for
corporate lending over the next year or so, but this is more down to weak demand
and reduced rates of return, than a lack of available funds. The situation is
not the same as the lending squeeze of the early 1990s when companies faced
sharply plummeting demand, but were also in financial deficit and faced a heavy
interest rate burden.”
Even so, it looks as though the heady days of merger and acquisition
activity are over for a bit, doesn’t it?
The credit crunch may have slowed M&A, but it won’t stop it in its tracks in
2008, says Andre Sawyer, managing editor of mergermarket.com. “We saw a number
of auctions put back to 2008 because the competitive tension isn’t in the market
at present,” he says. “But I think that once the credit market resolves itself,
you will see these auctions return, but largely in the mid-market deals
between £500m and £1bn,” he says.
Sawyer doesn’t believe there will be so much activity at the top of the
market in 2008 because the private equity players, who had started to challenge
trade buyers at this top level, can no longer command the debt leverage for
deals of that size.
“With the absence of the PE community at the top end of the scale, you won’t get
the same level of competitive tension and, therefore, prices will start to dr
op. That doesn’t mean that M&A itself is finished it just means that it
takes on a different tack.”
Indeed, at the lower end of the market, there is a healthy appetite for
deals. An autumn survey by Investec Private Bank, found that 37% of companies
with turnover of more than £10m are either “likely” or “very likely” to take
over another business during 2008.
Where does this leave hungry deal-makers in the PE
Facing a tougher 2008, but still doing some deals. “We will see fewer private
equity deals,” says Iain Roache, managing director at EA Consulting Group. “FDs
will have to go to market to raise funding which is more exposure than the FD
of a private equity company will be used to.”
But PwC’s Green thinks there will still be highly leveraged deals in 2008.
“Companies with the right fundamentals – good cash flows, solid management,
proven credit histories will still be able to generate high gearing. However,
banks will continue to be more cautious in their lending practices. There is an
obvious parallel to be drawn with the consumer lending market here, as mortgage
lenders shy away from the sub-prime market.
“You also have to remember that there is still a wall of money on the equity
side. Much of the war chest raised by private equity houses over the past few
years still needs investing, albeit deals will require greater equitisation.”
But the world of business won’t look so rosy in 2008 for instance,
what about high energy costs?
Continued growth from the Bric economies, especially China, is bound to keep
prices high, most commentators agree. Bestfortraders.com’s Kneale believes it’s
only a matter of time before the headline oil price breaches the totemic $100 a
Andrew Horstead, research manager at Utilyx, a provider of energy procurement
and price risk management services, agrees. “The only question that remains is
when, not if, the psychological $100 mark will be broken.”
This has implications for the way in which FDs manage corporate energy costs,
Horstead argues. “With future price direction still far from clear, and with
volatility expected to remain high, it has become more important for businesses
to incorporate a robust risk management policy into their day-to-day management
What about currency shifts, especially the weak dollar?
It’s likely that the US dollar will continue its relative decline, says Simon
Derrick, head of currency research at the Bank of New York Mellon. He argues
that one of the driving forces behind US currency policy has been worries about
the anti-inflationary stance of the Federal Reserve against a back-drop of
higher energy prices.
He says: “With all the signs also indicating that the US Treasury remains
comfortable with its currency policy, it seems likely that the dollar’s negative
forces emerging since mid-August 2007 will build in intensity. Indeed, as long
as this does not lead to a full-scale rout in US asset markets, it is arguable
that US officials may even be quite happy with this outcome if it brings further
pressure to bear upon those nations that currently peg their currencies or run
‘dirty floats’ against the dollar.”
But Mark O’Sullivan, at Currencies Direct, says: “Technically, the dollar
looks much oversold and, with the rest of the US economy growing at about 3.8% a
quarter, the news is not all bad. The fact that the American consumer has
started spending more on US products than imports should add to the
profitability of US companies so attracting currency flows from Asia and Europe.
“This, coupled with the fact that 2008 is an election year, means we could
see the dollar rebound. However, nothing is a certainty and as the saying goes,
24 hours is a long time in politics in the currency markets it is even
Where does this leave sterling and its implications for UK
Tony Wilson, director of Travelex Global Business Payments UK, says that, while
a quarter of UK businesses are bullish about the prospects for 2008, two-thirds
plan to rein in their international trade. “With half of the UK’s businesses
currently importing or exporting to North America, it is difficult to ignore the
potential impact of any further fall in the price of the US dollar or slowdown
in American consumer confidence beyond the Square Mile,” he says.
But not all pundits are convinced sterling will remain so strong against
other currencies. Ryan Kneale says: “While sterling remains very strong against
the dollar and that is likely to continue, in light of plunging banking stocks
in the UK and with uncertainly over interest rates, many analysts view sterling
as the next currency to collapse in dollar-like fashion. The sterling-to-euro
rate is currently falling and with interest rates in the UK higher than in the
eurozone, the euro is emerging as the currency of 2008.”
Can we expect to see the problem of pensions under-funding to be
resolved in 2008?
There are likely to be further developments that FDs will need to keep a close
eye on. The past few years have seen many pension fund trustees becoming
increasingly restless about the funding of schemes.
“That pressure will continue to build in 2008 and FDs will see more trustees
pushing for funding beyond FRS17 and some, depending on the circumstances, even
targeting gilts-matched funding,” says Jonathan Land, a partner at PwC. “This
raises the prospect of schemes having trapped surpluses as a result, with the
associated negative impacts on accounting disclosure. To manage the demands of
trustees, FDs should consider offering stronger covenants to trustees in return
for lower performance targets and/or greater flexibility in the investment
Land adds: “In 2008, we’re also likely to see an increase in the number of
schemes being bought out in corporate transactions as well as insurance
solutions. As the buyout market becomes more bullish, companies will want to
investigate the price at which they will be able to offload the unquantified
risk inherent in their schemes.”
And, on top of everything else, we’ll have to worry about becoming
greener, won’t we?
Business’s green agenda is likely to strengthen during 2008 and in the years
beyond. “Sustainability is becoming a fierce competitive issue for certain
sectors, particularly those with significant exposures to carbon, resource
intensity, waste and supply chain labour issues,” says Justin Keeble, head of
Arthur D Little’s sustainability and governance practice.
“European consumer attitudes are changing and will continue to manifest
themselves in their buying attitudes. We are seeing this strongly again in high
impact sectors such as automotive, where fuel efficiency has shifted other
purchasing criteria to become first choice and domestic energy, where there has
been a dramatic interest in green tariffs. We will see this extend to consumer
goods and retail. Leaders such as M&S are already taking advantage of this.
“Carbon reduction commitments will also bite industry, especially those with
significant energy exposure, but which are currently falling outside the
European Union’s Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS). These issues will have a
financial impact on the P&L and on shareholder value. FDs should start
pricing the cost of carbon into investment decisions,” he says.
More focus on the green agenda could encourage a swing back to sourcing goods
and services closer to home, argues Jonathan Russell, president of the UK200
group of accountancy firms. There are also supply chain considerations, he says.
“If it takes six weeks to ship goods from the Far East and they arrive faulty,
you have a major problem.”
So what’s the bottom line on 2008 for British business?
Sadly, it looks like tighter finances and more insolvencies. During the earlier
part of this year, there’s been a healthy level of restructuring and refinancing
activity. But, says Carolyn Swain, a corporate recovery partner at law firm
Halliwells, “We would not expect this situation to continue. Lenders are
reviewing their loan books and appear reluctant to lend more to some companies
where they are unhappy about the gearing of loans.
“In 2008, there is likely to be an upwards trend in formal insolvencies as
highly leveraged companies find that they are unable to refinance and their
existing lenders are no longer prepared to support them further,” says Swain.
“Additional pressure in the form of increased pension protection fund levies for
defined benefit scheme funds where the bill will almost inevitably be passed
on to the employer will also create more difficulties for employer companies
that may have been relying on refinancing to solve their problems.”